/Portals/64/20201023%20McLeod%20Final%20Decision%20Conclusion%20of%20Law_1.pdf/Portals/64/20201023%20McLeod%20Final%20Decision%20Conclusion%20of%20Law_1.pdf/Portals/64/20201023%20McLeod%20Final%20Decision%20Conclusion%20of%20Law.pdfThese documents are available in Adobe Acrobat PDF format. You will need Adobe Acrobat Reader to view and print it. If you do not already have Adobe Acrobat Reader installed on your computer, you may download the software for free.
For judicial review action of which we have been made aware, all attempts have been made to ensure the correctness of information relating to judicial review of decisions of the Montana Tax Appeal Board. All critical information should be independently verified.
- Kenneth & Tanya Kozimer v. Department of Revenue, PT-2020-26
- Department of Revenue v. Leroy & Patricia Coles, PT-2019-35
- Whitefish, LTD v. Department of Revenue, PT-2020-25
- Whitefish Investment Group LTD v. Department of Revenue, PT-2020-24
- David W. & Paula A. Ostby, Department of Revenue, PT-2020-4
- Christopher Cox v. Department of Revenue, PT-2020-6
- McLeod Family Trust v. MDOR, PT-2020-15
- MDOR v. Steven Brian Leland, PT-2020-5
- Robert & Patricia Thul v. Department of Revenue, PT-2019-21
- Colstrip Properties, Inc, & Richard Burnett v. DOR, PT-2018-67
- Colstrip Properties, Inc & Richard Burnett v. DOR, PT-2018-63
- Elvin & Crystal Hopper v. Department of Revenue, PT-2018-50
- David & Paula Ostby v. Department of Revenue, PT-2018-42
- Lawrence & Theresa Truchot, Trustees v. Department of Revenue, PT-2018-22
- Norman B. Carey v. Department of Revenue, PT-2018-9
- Joan Leslie Campbell v. Department of Revenue, PT-2017-37
- Timothy & Mary Ann Woods v. Department of Revenue, PT-2017-35
- Patrick Kelly, Julia Maxine LLC, St. Marie Housing LLC v. Dept. of Revenue, PT-2017-34
- Edward G. Beaudette v. Department of Revenue, PT-2017-35
- Stephen & Deanne Stalnaker v. Deparrtment of Revenue, PT-2017-16
- Starlo Mini Storage v. Department of Revenue, PT-2018-4
- Stephen J. Gillespie v. Department of Revenue, PT-2017-26
- Dwight & Beverly Axelsen v. Department of Revenue, PT-2017-22
- Robert J. & Patricia Thul v. Department of Revenue, PT-2017-24
- Thomas & Carole Angland v. Department of Revenue, PT-2017-23
- Wayne C. and Oxana Curry v. Department of Revenue, IT-2017-14
- James Sohm v. Department of Revenue, PT-2017-18
- LaVonne Sanders v. Department of Revenue, PT-2017-4
- Carl T. Schuneman v. Department of Revenue, PT-2017-5
- JEM, LLC v. Department of Revenue, PT-2017-6
- James S. Ferguson v. Department of Revenue, PT-2016-1
- John Richards v. Department of Revenue, PT-2016-21,22,23,24
- Timothy & Mary Ann Woods v. Department of Revenue, PT-2016-7
- Shannon Wadsworth v. Department of Revenue, PT-2016-35-39
- Ron S. Hill Living Trust v. Department of Revenue, PT-2016-11
- Thayer Development, LLC v. Department of Revenue, PT-2015-40
- William & Judy Fink v. Department of Revenue, PT-2016-34
- Bruce Anfinson v. Department of Revenue, PT-2016-28
- Paul and Margaret Gierach v. Department of Revenue, PT-2016-19
- John C. Brenden v. Department of Revenue, PT-2015-36
- Heather G. Richards v. Department of Revenue, PT-2015-31
- William T. Bliss v. Department of Revenue, PT-2016-3
- Jay & Deborah Getz v. Department of Revenue, PT-2016-9
- Department of Revenue v. Beaubien Family Trust, PT-2016-14
- Department of Revenue v. Edward Beaudette, PT-2016-17
- Department of Revenue v.Edward G. Beaudette, PT-2016-2
- William & Susan Antonioli v. Department of Revenue, PT-2015-21
- Gebhart, Laurie L. v. Department of Revenue, PT-2015-35
- ACDC, LLC v. Department of Revenue, PT-2016-10
- Kurt W. Unger v. Department of Revenue, PT-2015-27
- Daniel Klapan v. Department of Revenue, PT-2015-39
- Mark & Linda Ransford v. Department of Revenue, PT-2015-26
- Leonard & Marita Keppler v. Department of Revenue, PT-2015-24
- Carol Beyer-Ward, Michael Ward v. Department of Revenue, PT-2015-4, 3/25/16
- Yeager Family Trust v. Department of Revenue, PT-2015-3, 3/14/16
- Don Goodspeed v. Department of Revenue, PT-2015-3, 3/22/16
- Sheni, L.L.P. v. Department of Revenue, PT-2015-5, 2/26/15
- Fred Easy v. Department of Revenue, PT-2014-7, 07/30, 2015, 401kb)
- Department of Revenue v. Russell Lee Voytoski, Jr., PT-2013-26, 04/21/2015, 394kb)
- Department of Revenue v. CBA, LLC, PT-2013-25, 03/27/2015 (PDF 394 kb)
- Abbey/Land, LLC, v. Department of Revenue, PT-2013-12, 03/18/2015 (PDF1004kb)
- Christos and Tammi Vlahos v. Department of Revenue, PT-2014-3, 02/13/2015 (PDF484kb)
- W. Ray Jones v. Department of Revenue (Docket Nos.: PT-2012-22 through PT-2012-36, 08/28/2013) (PDF281kb)
- Stacey Lynn Keck v. Department of Revenue (Docket No: PT-2012-42, 06/05/2013) (PDF 217kb)
- Robert O. Thompson v. Department of Revenue, PT-2012-19, 03/13/2013) (PDF198 kb)
- Ron Trippet v. Department of Revenue, PT-2009-175, 09/06/2012) (PDF164kb)
- John M. and Beverlee E. Mollinet v. Department of Revenue, PT-2009-149, 12/14/11) (PDF133kb)
- W. Craig Heymann v. Department of Revenue, PT-2010-31, 11/23/11) (PDF 34kb)
- Homad LLC v. Department of Revenue, PT-2010-30, 11/17/11) (PDF 35kb)
- Springhill Enterprises, Inc., v. Department of Revenue, PT-2009-150 and 151, 10/18/11) (PDF39kb)
- Stephen and Carolyn Naso v. Department of Revenue, PT-2009-143, 10/06/11) (PDF34kb)
- Paul F. and Pamela M. Edwards v. Department of Revenue, PT-2010-25, 09/27/11) (PDF33kb)
- Tom, Steve, Karlene and Marco Kurilich and Ristene Hall v. Department of Revenue, PT-2010-24, 09/01/11) (PDF 35kb)
- Robert S. and Nancy C. Foster v. Department of Revenue, PT-2009-140, 08/22/11) (PDF 40kb)
- Norman B. Carey v. Department of Revenue, PT-2010-26, 07/15/11) (PDF32kb)
- Esther Suhr/William Waldron v. Department of Revenue, PT-2010-19, 06/03/11) (PDF34kb) The taxpayers filed a Petition for Judicial Review of this Board's decision in the First Judicial District, Broadwater County, Cause No. DV-2011-37, on July 14, 2011. By order dated January 13, 2012, district court affirmed this Board's decision.
- David Roe v. Department of Revenue, PT-2010-22, 04/13/11) (PDF27kb)
- Jerry T. Ray v. Department of Revenue, PT-2009-112I, 04/13/11) (PDF30kb)
- Lynn and Donna Weaver v. Department of Revenue (Docket Nos. PT-2010-16 through 18, 03/08/11) (PDF35kb)
- Jerry Meinhardt v. Department of Revenue (Docket No. PT-2010-10, 03/01/11, PDF30kb)
- TMH Enterprises, Inc., v. Department of Revenue (Docket No. PT-2009-118 and Department of Revenue cross appeal PT-2009-118X, 01/12/11, PDF 36kb)
- Patty L. and Orville Lovaas v. Department of Revenue (Docket No. PT-2009-117, 12/15/10, PDF 36kb)
- Donald Carson Cowles III v. Department of Revenue (Docket No. PT-2009-106, 11/17/10, PDF 34kb)
- Orville, Patty and Brian Lovaas v. Department of Revenue (Docket No. PT-2009-91, 11/16/10, PDF 32kb)
- Richard and Laura Bennett v. Department of Revenue (Docket No. PT-2009-103, 11/05/10, PDF 33kb)
- James C. Brager v. Department of Revenue (Docket No. PT-2009-44, 10/27/10, PDF 33kb)
- Jolene A. and Harve D. Murray v. Department of Revenue (Docket No. PT-2009-78, 10/18/10 PDF 39kb)
- Glen and Susan Green v. Department of Revenue (Docket No. PT-2009-64, 10/08/10, PDF 33kb)
- Michael S. Rogers v. Department of Revenue (Docket No. PT-2009-98, 10/04/10, PDF 23kb)
- Moss Family Trust v. Department of Revenue (Docket No. PT-2009-77, 09/21/10, PDF 20kb)
- Daniel J. and Bonnie R. Gebhardt v. Department of Revenue (Docket No. PT-2009-63A-I, 08/17/10, PDF 23kb)
- Bonnie M. and Elwin L. Manicke v. Department of Revenue (Docket No. PT-2009-67, 08/17/10, PDF 22kb)
- L. D. and Ruth Renfrew v. Department of Revenue (Docket No. PT-2009-16, 08/17/10, PDF 22kb)
- Shane T. Kelly v. Department of Revenue (Docket No. PT-2009-40, 07/28/10, PDF 25kb)
- Orville W. and Mary Lou Chigbrow v. Department of Revenue (Docket No. PT-2009-41, 06/16/10, PDF 27kb)
- Department of Revenue v. Stephen D. and Peggy A. Woods (Docket Nos. PT-2009-38 and cross-appeal PT-2009-42, 05/21/10, 48kb)
- CBA, LLC v. Department of Revenue (Docket Nos. PT-2009-28 and PT-2009-31, 05/19/10, 25kb)
- James Leroy Sayler v. Department of Revenue (Docket No. PT-2009-8, 05/18/10, 25kb)
- Rick Shannon v. Department of Revenue (Docket No. PT-2009-7, 05/14/10, 27kb)
- James L. Kilhof v. Department of Revenue (Docket No. PT-2009-19, 04/29/10, 30kb)
- Preston and Debra Jones v. Department of Revenue (Docket No. PT-2009-3, 03/02/10, 45kb)
- Paul Neal Cooley v. Department of Revenue , (Docket No. PT-2008-4, 04/20/09, 65kb)
- John and Tracie Grimm v. Department of Revenue , (Docket No. PT-2008-1, 01/21/09, 78kb)
- Warren J. and Marcheta M. Becker v. Department of Revenue , (Docket No. PT-2006-13, 10/09/07, 63kb)
- Department of Revenue v. Michael and Erin Bengala , (Docket No. PT-2006-10, 07/11/07, 86kb)
- Gary L. Laufer v. Department of Revenue , (Docket No. PT-2006-4, 05/29/07, 66kb)
- Robert and Susan Osborn v. Department of Revenue , (Docket No. PT-2006-3, 01/22/07, 63kb)
- Bonnie M. and Elwin L. Manicke v. Department of Revenue , (Docket No. PT-2005-5, 08/31/06, 75kb)
- Mildred Cox v. Department of Revenue, (Docket No. PT-2005-11, 05/23/06, 49 kb)
- Curt Cox v. Department of Revenue (Docket No. PT-2005-9, 05/23/06, 40 kb)
- Consonants, Inc. v. Department of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-2005-8, 05/23/06, 74kb (Nunc Pro Tunc order issued June 14, 2006)
- (Docket No.: PT-2003-36, 08/26/05, 43kb)
- Shannon Wadsworth v. Department of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-2003-119, 08/11/05, 113kb)
- Shannon Wadsworth v. Department of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-2003-118, 08/11/05, 105kb)
- Shannon Wadsworth v. Department of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-2003-117, 08/11/05, 106kb)
- Dennis L. and Jane A. Garnett v. Department of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-2004-10, 07/22/05) (PDF, 36kb)
- JoAnn Spolar vs. Department of Revenue (Docket Nos.: PT-2003-77 through 85, 03/28/05) (PDF, 32kb)
- Jerry T. Ray vs. Department of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-2003-72, 02/25/05) (PDF, 23kb)
- Dan L. and Patty L. Munson vs. Department of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-2003-39, 02/07/05) (PDF, 28kb)
- Sharon Ann Warren vs. Department of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-2003-51, 01/07/05) (PDF, 43kb)
- Department of Revenue vs. Bruce and Susan Tate (Docket No.: PT-2003-106 and 107, 12/27/04) (PDF, 62kb)
- Jerry D. Crisp and Linda Thorgersen vs. Department of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-2003-98, 11/17/04) (PDF, 383kb)
- Blickenstaff Rev. Trust/Rebecca R. Blickenstaff Rev. Trust, Robert A. vs. Department of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-2003-41, 10/05/04) (Word, 102kb)
- Department of Revenue vs. Valuent A. and Shirley D. Thompson (Docket No.: PT-2003-21, 09/28/04) (PDF, 165kb)
- George and Kathleen F. Sayler vs. Department of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-2003-20, 09/21/04) (PDF, 343kb)
- James LeRoy Sayler vs. Department of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-2003-19, 09/21/04) (PDF, 341kb)
- Kevin Osterberg and Marilyn Ash vs. Department of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-2003-38, 09/03/04) (PDF, 410kb)
- Stacey Lynn Wohl vs. Department of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-2003-14, 09/03/04)(PDF, 224kb)
- Department of Revenue vs. Keith P. and Lydia P. Rhea (Docket No.: PT-2003-22, 08/18/04) (PDF, 452kb)
- Arthur R. and Mary C. Vender vs. Department of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-2003-38, 08/04/04) (PDF, 139kb)
- Kelly D. Manzer vs. Department of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-2003-40, 07/19/04) (PDF, 19kb)
- Department of Revenue vs. Kathleen Curd Rau (Docket No.: PT-2003-53, 06/02/04) (PDF, 19kb)
- June K. Gessaman vs. Department of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-2003-11, 05/28/04) (Word, 70kb)
- Ronald and Kathleen Gessaman vs. Department of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-2003-8, 05/25/04) (Word, 103kb)
- Department of Revenue vs. Harvey and Constance Tice (Docket No.: PT-2003-35, 05/19/04) (PDF, 22kb)
- Department of Revenue vs. Clayton R. Johnson (Docket No.: PT-2003-6, 05/17/04) (PDF, 18kb)
- Department of Revenue vs. Jimmy McCabe (Docket No.: PT-2003-7, 05/04/04) (PDF, 14kb)
- Department of Revenue vs. Dona L. Perkins (Docket No.: PT-2003-9, 05/04/04) (PDF, 19kb)
- Malcolm W. Birdsong vs. Department of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-2003-75, 3/15/04) (PDF, 12kb)
- Merlin C. and Melinda Birdsong vs. Department of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-2003-74, 3/15/04) (PDF, 12kb)
- Merlin C. and Melinda Birdsong vs. Department of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-2003-73, 3/15/04) (PDF, 13kb)
- Colstrip Properties, Inc., vs. Department of Revenue, PT-2003-23, 3/10/04 (PDF, 19kb)
- Maureen P. Dougherty vs. Department of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-2002-10, 07/08/03) (PDF, 74kb)
- Evelyn Timmons vs. Department of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-2002-14, 4/9/03) (PDF, 94kb)
- Michael Higgins vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-2002-3, 01/09/03) (PDF, 38kb)
- Consonants, Inc., vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-2000-10, 08/24/01) (PDF, 18kb)
- Buffalo Bill Road, Inc., vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-2000-12, 08/24/01) (PDF, 18kb)
- Robert G. and Billie L. DeMarois vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-2000-15, 06/20/01) (PDF, 46kb)
- Victoria M.P. Zell vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1999-10, 09/01/00) (PDF, 38kb) (Taxpayer filed an appeal in the First Judicial District in Lewis and Clark County, under cause number BDV-2000-687, on June 8, 2001. By order dated July 26, 2001, district court affirmed this Board's decision.)
- Jay & Nadine Greene vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1999-5, 4/20/00) (PDF, 22kb)
- Marvin L. & Edith C. McDonald vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1998-1, 4/21/99) (PDF, 20kb)
- James E. & Wilma R. Pilgeram vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1997-2, 12/8/98) (PDF, 17kb)
- Department of Revenue v. Constance M. Nelson (Docket No.: PT-1997-59) (PDF, 15kb)
- 1804, Inc vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1997-51, 8/4/98) (PDF, 17kb)
- Michael J. Gonsior vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1997-32, 8/15/98) (PDF, 23kb)
- Richard & Jane Erickson vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1997-156, 8/19/98) (PDF, 28kb)
- Michael and Elizabeth Smith vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1997-36, 8/4/98) (PDF, 21kb)
- Arthur R. Vender vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1997-128, 6/15/98) (PDF, 19kb)
- Cornelius & Vera S. Wall vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1997-9, 6/17/98) (PDF, 18kb)
- Homer J. Philips C/O John A.& Arlene N. Wall vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1997-8, 6/17/98) (PDF, 32kb)
- Frederick N. & Joan T. Wolf v. Department of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1999-9, 02/29/00) (PDF, 25kb)
- O.P. & Dona Morrow v. Department of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1999-6, 02/29/00) (PDF, 51kb)
- Dennis P. Clarke vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1997-12,12/10/99) (PDF, 46kb)
- Tom V. and/or Loyce V. Howard vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1997-13,11/23/99) (PDF, 14kb)
- Roseanne Sorvig vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1998-13,11/12/99) (PDF, 24kb)
- Eloise J. Duford vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1998-23, 9/8/99) (PDF, 14kb)
- David R. and Linda P. Lee vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1997-115, 9/1/99) (PDF, 62kb)
- Roy Stanley vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1998-5, 8/18/99) (PDF, 29kb)
- June Gessaman. vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1997-16, 4/21/99) (PDF, 25kb)
- Ronald L. And Kathleen Gessaman vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1997-17, 4/20/99) (PDF, 24kb)
- Lane A. & Shelly M. Rammell vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1998-26, 4/20/99) (PDF, 28kb)
- Robert G. Brohaugh vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1997-65 & 1997-88, 4/22/99) (PDF, 19kb)
- Kevin Detienne vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1997-134, 4/6/99) (PDF, 10kb)
- Richard & Alma Ecklund vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1997-57, 12/7/98) (PDF, 15kb)
- L. G. & Phyllis Murdock vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1997-31, 12/9/98) (PDF, 28kb)
- Fred A. & Diana Johnson vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1997-5, 12/9/98) (PDF, 15kb)
- Patricia Banis vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1997-14, 12/9/98) (PDF, 15kb)
- Richard N. Higgins vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1997-22, 12/9/98) (PDF, 22kb)
- Russell B. & Mary Sparrow vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1997-1, 12/8/98) (PDF, 15kb)
- Russell E.& Sandra C. Meech vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1997-4, 12/8/98) (PDF, 15kb)
- Terry O. Ferrell, A.K.A Terry O'neill Barber vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1997-40, 12/10/98) (PDF, 14kb)
- Linda L. Kingsley vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1997-140, 11/5/98) (PDF, 19kb)
- Michael P. Mcleod vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1997-101, 9/30/98) (PDF, 24kb)
- Connie Everly vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1997-104, 9/30/98) (PDF, 19kb)
- Christopher Lance Richards vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1997-76,PT-1997-77, PT-1997-78 8/6/97) (PDF, 18kb)
- Louise M. Beighle vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1997-7, 11/4/98) (PDF, 18kb)
- Siegfried & Ingrid Fuhrmann vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1997-45, & PT-1997-46, 8/18/98) (PDF, 23kb)
- Robert J. & Joan K. Ryan vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1997-131, 8/20/98) (PDF, 17kb)
- J. Turner vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT-1997-119, 10/1/98) (PDF, 23kb)
- Alice Peterson and Nelly Chaney vs. Dept. of Revenue (Docket No.: PT 1997-102, 4/23/98) (PDF, 26kb)